Friday, November 15, 2013

RETOLD Review: Juliet Immortal (Forgotten Fridays #1) (Re-Telling Reads Month #2)

Today includes two features with one review-- Forgotten Fridays and a re-telling of Romeo & Juliet as part of my Re-Telling Reads Month.

Forgotten Fridays is a wonderful new feature started by the ladies at Great Imaginations. It's to focus on books hanging out on our TBR shelves, or whatever you may like to read, that are at least a year or so older. They came up with this fun concept after realizing there are still books out there needing attention other than just the newest releases or ARCs. This feature helps gets those reviews and comments out, along with hopefully finding some hidden gems along the way. I'm planning to make Forgotten Friday review posts at least one or two Fridays out of the month. If you want to learn more, make sure you stop by their blog!

Also, Re-Telling Reads Month continues with this review of Juliet Immortal, a re-telling of Romeo & Juliet! If you haven't read what this is about yet, you can check out my post on what I'm doing with this feature here.

Title: Juliet Immortal
Author: Stacey Jay
Category/Genre: YA, Paranormal, Fantasy, Romance

See it at Amazon | See it at BAM

The most tragic love story in history . . .

Juliet Capulet didn't take her own life. She was murdered by the person she trusted most, her new husband, Romeo Montague, a sacrifice made to ensure his own immortality. But what Romeo didn't anticipate was that Juliet would be granted eternity, as well, and would become an agent for the Ambassadors of Light. For 700 years, she's fought Romeo for the souls of true lovers, struggling to preserve romantic love and the lives of the innocent. Until the day she meets someone she's forbidden to love, and Romeo, oh Romeo, will do everything in his power to destroy that love.

I have a mild obsession with all things Shakespeare. Okay. Not mild. Probably classified insane. Whatever. Everyone knows it. And when it comes to getting my interest in any modern re-telling, you’re going to certainly get it if it has to do Shakespeare. So what if I’ve read Romeo & Juliet a thousand times? Or if I’ve read it in a number of variations through the years from other re-tellings? I don’t care. I’ll still give it a try anyway because it’s R & J and based on one of my favorite reads of all time.

“The greatest love story ever told is a lie.”

Naturally, when Juliet Immortal released (in early 2011, I believe?), I wanted it bad. That synopsis? Golden. Not the usual story recycle or anything of that sort. Really sounded like a re-telling with a fresh concept. Unfortunately, I didn’t get the book for some time due to funds, busy schedule, etc.. And when I finally bought it earlier this summer from a clearance sale, I was excited all over again. Also, that tag was enough to get my attention as it was anyway. I didn’t even have to read the synopsis to know I was going to want to read this book. **Though, I need to side note here and say that I feel like people may put too much claim into R & J being a “great love story.” Or is that just me? One of my faves, yes, but I’ve never viewed it as a love story and I still don’t get it. But that’s for a whole separate discussion later! I’m getting off topic! :P

But there was a problem with Juliet Immortal. It completely disappointed me. I probably should’ve expected it though. It really is hard for me to LOVE a re-telling, particularly a Shakespeare one, and this was just another one to add to the pile of blaaaahhh. In fact, if it hadn’t been for the names and a few note toss-ins during the story about the their past, it really could have been just a separate piece all together with no connection at all. I like a re-telling to feel like its own story, but I also like to feel that connection to the original piece as well. I know I mentioned above how much I loved the fresh concept of the idea, and I did and still do, but I still felt disconnected once I’d read. I’m not sure if that makes much sense, but it’s hard to explain really.

I almost marked this as a DNF before I even reached fifty pages in because it starts out a bit dull, and the narrative is so wah wah wah wah… Then there’s also the insta-love, as if Juliet hadn’t learned from her past mistakes enough as it is. But I pushed on because I really did need to get some reading done. I’ve been slacking so bad the last few weeks with NaNo and the family life keeping me busy. It does get better as it gets further along, and I think the story has an interesting plot idea for the re-telling with Romeo and Juliet’s continuation. I would’ve liked a bit more oomph and detail or more background information for better understanding in the beginning. Twists and turns did keep me wanting to turn the pages. And despite my love for the original play and characters, I find it incredibly amusing to take the two and create such a mess between them with this one. I’d love to read another re-telling in the future with something similar to this type of relationship----the idea of Romeo and Juliet hating each other or a what-if (they’d never met)? I think it’d be interesting!

I do give it unique points for the imaginative idea and a thumbs up for managing to grab my attention again. But not one of the better re-tellings I’ve read in recent years. I doubt I’ll continue to the next book because I didn’t find enough curiosity at the end to want it. The writing was well done, even if a bit dry at times--and I’d look forward to reading more from the author in the future I’m sure. :)


  1. That is so sad to hear. It had some promise in it. What a neat concept. BAH.

  2. I agree with you about the premise -- it sounds really unique and fascinating. There's so much raw material for conflict and drama. Too bad it starts slow, takes a while to pick up, and didn't live up to its potential. But congrats on finally getting to it and actually finishing it. As a person with too many DNF's hanging about my nightstand, that's no small accomplishment. Have a great weekend! :-)


Drop a line! We love having your comments!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...